H. I

268

APPENDICES.

APPENDIX A. Report of Preliminary Discussion. [Not printed.]

APPENDIX B. List of Witnessks. 1. Batchelor, Ferdinand Campion-Mem. E. Coll. Surg. Eng. 1871. Lie. R. Coll. Phys. Page Ed. 1871. M.D. Univ. Durh. 1885 ... ... ... ... 11,14,28,42,66,81 2. Maunsell, Henry Widenham—Mem. E. Coll. Surg. Eng. 1867. Bach. Med. Univ. Dubl. 1867. Lie. Midwif. K. &Q. Coll. Phys. Irel. 1867 ..'. . . ... 121, 142, 156 3. Roberts, William Stewart Weeding—Mem. R. Coll. Surg. Eng. 1876 ... 74, 103, 266 4. Fergusen, Henry Lindo- Lie. K. & Q. Coll. Phys. Irel. 1880. Lie. 1880; Fell, 1883; R. Coll. Surg. Irel. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 93 5. Closs, Joseph Osborne-Bach. Med., Mast. Surg., Univ. Edin. 1882 ... ... 116 6. DeLautour, Harry Archibald—Mem. E. Coll. Surg. Eng. 1874 ... ... ... 107 7. King, Frederick Truby—Bach. Med., Mast. Surg., Univ. Edin. 1886 ... 132, 139, 263 8. Deßenzi, Arthur Castriol —Mem. R. Coll. Surg. Eng. 1887. Lie. Soe. Apoth. Lond. 1887 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 123 9. Macdonald, Robert Gordon Lie. E. Coll. Phys. Edin. 1881. Lie. Fac. Phys. & Surg. Glasg. 1876 ... ... ... ... " ... ... ... ... ... 145 10. Stenhouse, William MacStravick- -Bach. Med., Mast. Surg., Univ. Glasg. 1875. M.D. Univ. Glasg. 1877 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 171 11. Jeffcoat, Frederick Howarth—Bach. Med., Ma^st. Surg., Univ. Edin. 1886 ... 184 12. Colquhoun, Daniel—Mem. E. Coll. Surg. Eng. 1877. Mem. R. Coll. Phys. Lond. 1880. M.D. Univ. Lond. 1880 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 204 13. Ogston, Francis- -Mast. Surg. 1873. M.D. Univ. Aberd. 1875 ... ... ... 198 14. Macdonald, John—Lie. R. Coll. Phys.; Lie. Midwif. Edin. 1864. Lie. R. Coll. Svirg., and Lie. Midwif. Edin. 1858. Lie. Midwif. R. Coll. Surg. Eng. 1866 ... ... 219 15. Coughtrey, Millen—Bach. Med., Mast. Surg. Univ. Edin. ... ... 235,236 16. Copland,' George Anderson—Bach. Med. Univ. N.Z. 1889 ... ... 158, 162, 234 17. Robert Henry Hogg, Clinical Clerk ... ... ... ... ... ... 216 LB. Peter Miller, Chairman of Trustees ... ... ... ... ... ... 217 19. Andrew Burns, Hospital Steward ... ... ... ... ... ... 256 20. N. Y. A. Wales, Architect ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 222 21. Mrs. Janet Burton, Hospital Matron ... ... ... ... ... 226 22. Miss Mary Ellen Eraser, Nurse ... ... ... ... ... ... 227 23. Miss Caroline Shaw, Nurse ... ... ... ... ... ... 228 •24. Miss Mary Waymouth, Nurse ... ... ... ... ... ... 229 25. Miss Ellen Maria Monson, Nurse ... ... ... ... ... ... 233

APPENDIX C. List of Documents submitted and referred to in the evidence. By Dr. Batchelor : Complaint of 19th August, 1890, No. i. Letter to Chairman, Hospital Trustees, 22nd July; No. ii. Report of medical staff, 27th May, 1889; No. iii. Table of deathrates in Hospital; No. iv. Minute-book of the medical staff, page 166; No. v. Ditto, page 143; No. vi. Scrap-book, p. 31, a, and b; No. vii. Statement of cases to medical staff; No. viii. Letters to Trustees in Mrs. T 's case; No. ix. Wilson's "Hygiene," p. 261; No. x. Plans of wards, Nos. 1 and?; No. xi. " Ashurst," p. 1110; No. xii. Amount of bed-space; No. xiii. •'Erichsen," 1., p. 13; No. xiv. " Lawson Tait," p. 133; No. xv. "Spencer Wells;" No. xvi. ■'Heath," 11., p. 417; No. xvii. Memorandum from Trustees to Dr. Batchelor, scrap-book; No. xviii. Letter —Dr. Barclay to Dr. Batchelor, 9th August, 1890 ; No. xix. Table of cases, 9th to 22nd July; No. xx. Evening Star, 12th March, 1889; No. xxi. Letter —Dr. Batchelor to Trustees, scrap-book, p. 57 ; No. xxii. Extract from Dr. Batchelor's note-book, showing deaths in Hospital and private practice ; No. xxiv. Comparative list of operations in Christchurch and Dunedin Hospitals for 1889-90 ; No. lxii. By Trustees : Eeports of Trustees, 1886-90 ; No. xxiii. Dunedin Hospital By-laws ; No. xxv. Need of Hospital reform, suggestions by Dr. Batchelor, see p. 1, scrap-book; No. xxvi. Mrs. T., chart; No. xxvii. Mrs. P., chart; No. xxviii. Mrs. S., chart; No. xxix. Letter—Dr. Batchelor to Trustees, 24th May, 1886 ; No. xxx. Circular to hospital staff from Trustees, 7th August, 1890; No. xxxviii. By Dr. Eoberts : Eeport by Dr. Roberts, 27th October, 1884 ; No. xxxi. By Dr. DeLautour : Plans of syphon-traps ; No. xxxii. By Dr. Truby' King: Diagram of Dunedin Hospital traps ; No. xxxiii. Diagram of traps at Seacliff; No. xxxiv. Diagram of drains at Wellington Hospital; No. xxxv. Section of drains at Wellington Hospital; No. xxxyi. By Dr. DeEenzi: Plan of a ward in Chrisfcchurch Hospital; No. xxxvii. List of operations in the Christchurch Hospital; No. liv. By Dr. Copland: Deaths in Dunedin Hospital within one week of admission; No. xxxix. Return of percentage of deaths in four hospitals; No. xl. Return of patients beyond two months'